Source:Dainik Bhaskar
Subject: Governance, Public Service Commissions and Recruitment Rules (Polity and Governance)|Target exams: RPSC RAS, RSSB
Key points for Prelims: Rajasthan Public Service Commission (RPSC), 40:20:40 selection formula, Rajasthan Medical Service Rules, 1962, Special leave petition (Article 136), Interview weightage cap of 10%
Mains syllabus mapping
- General Studies Paper 2: Governance, Constitution, Polity, Public Service Commissions, service recruitment rules, role of judiciary in administrative matters
- General Studies Paper 2: Issues relating to development and management of social sector: education and health human resources, medical education
Key facts for one-day exams
- The recruitment covers 337 assistant professor posts in Rajasthan government medical colleges.
- The Rajasthan Public Service Commission used a 40:20:40 selection formula.
- The original recruitment advertisement was issued on 27 November 2021.
- The High Court division bench gave its decision on 27 October 2026.
- The 2022 amendment to Rule 19 capped interview weightage at 10%.
Rajasthan assistant professor recruitment: why in the news?
The Supreme Court's dismissal of the special leave petition on the 337 assistant professor posts removes the final legal hurdle, allowing the remaining candidates to join within a week and settling the applicability of the 2022 interview cap for this recruitment.
The Supreme Court has cleared the recruitment of 337 assistant professors in Rajasthan's government medical colleges, dismissing a special leave petition filed by Amit Sharma against the Rajasthan High Court's decision. The High Court's division bench had on 27 October 2026 upheld the 40:20:40 selection formula used by the Rajasthan Public Service Commission (RPSC) for these posts. The remaining candidates are expected to complete their joining within one week.
The selection formula assigns 40% weightage to the screening test, 20% to academic qualifications and 40% to the interview. The petitioner had sought the application of a 2022 amendment to Rule 19 of the Rajasthan Medical Service Rules, 1962, which caps interview weightage at 10%. The High Court ruled that the rules in force when the original advertisement was issued on 27 November 2021 would govern this recruitment, not the later amendment.
What was the dispute about?
The dispute centred on whether the 2022 amendment to Rule 19 of the Rajasthan Medical Service Rules, 1962, which caps interview weightage at 10%, should apply to the recruitment advertised on 27 November 2021. The RPSC's original selection formula gave 40% weightage to the screening test, 20% to academic qualifications and 40% to the interview. The High Court held that the rules in force on the advertisement date govern the recruitment, not the later amendment.
What happens next?
The remaining candidates are expected to complete their joining within one week. The Supreme Court's decision leaves the High Court's ruling intact for this specific recruitment, but the 2022 amendment capping interview weightage at 10% remains applicable to future recruitments under the Rajasthan Medical Service Rules.
Interview weightage in the recruitment dispute
| Basis | Interview weightage | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Recruitment formula | 40% | Upheld for this recruitment |
| 2022 Rule 19 amendment | Maximum 10% | Sought by petitioner |
Rajasthan connection
Key terms
- Special leave petition:
- A petition requesting the Supreme Court's special permission to appeal against a judgment or order.
- Division bench:
- A court bench comprising two or more judges.
- Selection weightage:
- The proportion assigned to a selection component when assessing candidates.
Rajasthan assistant professor recruitment: why it matters for exams
Exams: RPSC RAS, RSSB
Syllabus: Governance: Public service recruitment; Polity: Judiciary and appeals
Common mistake: Examiners may present the 2022 amendment's 10% interview cap as the weightage applied to this recruitment; the upheld formula assigns 40% to the interview.
Mains practice questions
Question 1(GS-2 | 250 words | 15 marks)
Recruitment through a combined weightage of written test, academic record and interview is often defended as merit-based but is also criticised for subjectivity. Critically examine the role of the interview in public service selection and suggest safeguards to make it fair and transparent.
Answer outline
- Introduction: Open by noting that the Rajasthan case, where 40% of marks rest on the interview under the 40:20:40 formula, shows how the interview remains a central but contested tool in recruitment.
- Body:
- Argue for the interview: it assesses communication, aptitude, and suitability for teaching and clinical roles that a written test cannot capture.
- Highlight the concerns: scope for subjective bias, lack of uniform standards across boards, and the risk of arbitrary marking when weightage is high.
- Reference the legal dimension: the 2022 amendment capping interview weightage at 10% reflects a judicial and policy concern that excessive interview weight undermines objectivity.
- Discuss why the High Court held that rules in force at the time of advertisement govern a recruitment, and its implications for reform and legitimate expectation of candidates.
- Suggest safeguards: structured interviews with defined rubrics, recorded proceedings, diverse panels, and disclosure of marking criteria.
- Conclusion: A balanced approach keeps the interview as a tool for assessing suitability while constraining its weight and subjectivity through transparent rules, so that merit and public trust reinforce each other.
Question 2(GS-2 | 150 words | 10 marks)
Changes to recruitment rules during an ongoing selection process raise questions of fairness to candidates. Evaluate the principle that the rules in force at the time of advertisement should govern a recruitment, with reference to the 337 assistant professor posts in Rajasthan.
Answer outline
- Introduction: Open with the Rajasthan case: the High Court held that the 2021 advertisement, not the 2022 amendment capping interview weight at 10%, governed the 337 posts.
- Body:
- Support the principle: it protects legitimate expectations of candidates who applied under known rules, and ensures certainty and fairness in recruitment.
- Note the counter-view: rules that improve transparency or prevent arbitrariness may warrant prospective application to serve public interest.
- Mention the role of the judiciary in deciding such disputes, including dismissal of the special leave petition that closed the matter.
- Point to the need for clear transitional provisions in service rules to avoid such litigation.
- Conclusion: The principle of applying the rules in force at advertisement strengthens fairness, but government should pair it with clear transitional provisions so that reforms are not stalled while candidates remain secure.
Stuck? Get it in one tap
The selection formula gives different shares of the assessment to a test, qualifications and an interview. The High Court held that the rules existing when the posts were advertised applied, not the later interview cap. The Supreme Court declined to interfere, and the remaining candidates are expected to join within one week.
- Governance: Public service recruitment
- Polity: Judiciary and appeals
Related concepts: Special leave petition, Division bench, Selection weightage
Practice questions
Pick an answer, then read the explanation.
- Q1Easy
Which body used the 40:20:40 selection formula for Rajasthan's recruitment of 337 assistant professors?
Explanation: The Rajasthan Public Service Commission used the 40:20:40 selection formula. The High Court upheld it, while the Supreme Court declined to interfere; government medical colleges are where the posts are located.
- Q2Hard
Consider the following statements about Rajasthan's recruitment of 337 assistant professors:
- 1. The selection formula assigns 20% weightage to academic qualifications.
- 2. The original recruitment advertisement was issued on 27 November 2021.
- 3. The High Court applied the 2022 amendment's 10% interview cap to the recruitment.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
Explanation: Statements 1 and 2 are correct: academic qualifications carry 20% and the advertisement was issued on 27 November 2021. Statement 3 is incorrect: the High Court upheld the earlier formula with 40% interview weightage.
- Q3Medium
What maximum interview weightage was prescribed by the 2022 amendment to Rule 19 of the Rajasthan Medical Service Rules, 1962?
Explanation: The 2022 amendment prescribed a maximum interview weightage of 10%. The upheld recruitment formula instead gave 40% to the interview and 20% to academic qualifications.
- Q4Medium
Which rules did the Rajasthan High Court hold applicable to the 337 assistant professor recruitment?
Explanation: The High Court held that the rules in force on the advertisement date governed the recruitment. It therefore upheld the existing formula rather than applying the later 2022 interview cap.
Frequently asked questions
1. What was the Supreme Court's decision on Rajasthan's 337 assistant professor posts?
The Supreme Court dismissed Amit Sharma's special leave petition and declined to interfere with the High Court decision upholding the selection formula.
2. What is the selection formula for Rajasthan's 337 assistant professor posts?
The formula assigns 40% to the screening test, 20% to academic qualifications and 40% to the interview.
3. Why did the 2022 interview cap not apply to this Rajasthan recruitment?
The High Court held that the rules in force when the original advertisement was issued on 27 November 2021 governed the recruitment.
4. When are the remaining Rajasthan assistant professor candidates expected to join?
The remaining candidates are expected to complete joining within one week.
All sources
Original21 November 2026 · Read story


