Source:Indian Express
Subject: Polity and Governance: Judiciary, Criminal Law and Women's Rights|Target exams: UPSC
Key points for Prelims: Section 498A IPC (cruelty by husband or relatives), Section 2(f) Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, Section 11 Hindu Marriage Act (void marriage), Indra Sarma v VKV Sarma (2013), Reema Aggarwal v Anupam (2004), Mischief rule (Heydon's case)
Mains syllabus mapping
- General Studies Paper 2: Functions and responsibilities of the Union and the judiciary; judicial interpretation versus legislative authority; separation of powers
- General Studies Paper 2: Issues relating to women: laws for women's protection and their interpretation

Key facts for one-day exams
- Section 498A IPC concerns cruelty by a husband or his relatives.
- Section 2(f) of the domestic violence law defines domestic relationship.
- Section 5(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act requires neither party to have a living spouse at marriage.
- Indra Sarma v VKV Sarma was decided in 2013.
- The mischief rule traces its origin to Heydon’s case.
Section 498A and live-in relationships: why in the news?
The Supreme Court's decision in Dr Lokesh B H v State of Karnataka permits a Section 498A cruelty charge in a live-in relationship with 'intent to marry', raising a debate on judicial interpretation versus legislative authority in criminal law.
The Supreme Court has ruled that a man in a live-in relationship can be prosecuted under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code, which criminalises cruelty by a husband or his relatives towards a married woman. The decision in Dr Lokesh B H & Ors v State of Karnataka & Anr introduces the concept of 'intent to marry' into the framework of live-in relationships. The columnist argues that this effectively creates a new legal principle without legislative intervention. The case involved an accused who allegedly concealed an existing marriage and entered into a second marriage with the respondent.
The Court agreed with the high court that the charge under Section 498A was maintainable, rejecting the argument that the provision could not apply to a live-in relationship as an 'unduly technical construction'. The column by Shantanu Sudheer Shastri argues that this approach expands the scope of a criminal statute beyond its 'reasonable words', bypassing the legislature. The Court built on earlier decisions, including Reema Aggarwal v Anupam (2004), which extended the meaning of 'husband' to void marriages, and Indra Sarma v VKV Sarma (2013), which distinguished between a woman who knowingly enters a void marriage and one who does so unaware of the man's existing marriage.
Key features and how it works
- The IPC is a comprehensive criminal code covering substantive offences, and it is exhaustive on the matters it declares the law on.
- The IPC did not repeal penal laws in force when it came into effect, because it did not contain all offences. Other penal statutes existed alongside it.
- Section 498A was added to the IPC in 1983 to protect married women from cruel treatment by husbands and in-laws.
- The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 recognises an aggrieved person's right to file a complaint under Section 498A of the IPC.
Related Static GK and comparison
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023: passed by Parliament in December 2023, received the President's assent on 25 December 2023, came into effect on 1 July 2024, and replaced the IPC with 20 chapters and 358 sections.
- Mischief rule: a rule of statutory interpretation first set out in Heydon's Case (1584), used to find the mischief a statute seeks to remedy; it is one of three traditional English rules of interpretation, with the plain meaning rule and golden rule.
- Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005: a civil law that came into force on 26 October 2006 and defines domestic violence.
- Hindu Marriage Act, 1955: an Act of Parliament enacted in 1955 to codify marriage law for Hindus, with Section 5 setting the condition that neither party has a spouse living at the time of marriage.
IPC and BNS on the same subject
| Basis | Indian Penal Code, 1860 | Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 |
|---|---|---|
| Legal status | Replaced in December 2023 and in force until 1 July 2024 | Official criminal code from 1 July 2024 |
| Structure | 23 chapters and 511 sections | 20 chapters and 358 sections |
| Treatment of sedition | Sedition was an offence in the IPC | Sedition removed; replaced by an offence on acts endangering sovereignty, unity and integrity |
Achievements
- Section 498A gave married women a criminal remedy against cruelty by husbands and in-laws. The Supreme Court allowed a charge under it to proceed in the specific Lokesh case involving a live-in relationship and intent to marry.
Challenges
- Interpretation of a criminal statute beyond its words, as in the live-in case, raises the debate between judicial interpretation and legislative authority.
- The code is partly colonial in origin and its section on same-sex relations was changed only through court rulings in 2009, 2013 and 2018, showing that courts, not Parliament, drove change on that issue.
- Section 309 of the IPC penalised attempted suicide. Section 115(1) of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 effectively decriminalised it, and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita does not include an equivalent to Section 309.
Way forward
- Legislative clarity on whether live-in partners and void marriages fall within section 498A would reduce the scope for judicial reinterpretation of a criminal statute.
- Monitoring how the BNS handles offences carried over from the IPC will show whether the new code closes the gaps seen in the old one.
- Awareness of the protection available under the domestic violence law and criminal provisions, so that women know their remedies, is needed for effective use.
Connected to this news
Indian Penal Code, 1860
The Indian Penal Code, 1860 was India's general criminal code, which was replaced by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita in 2024, and it continues to govern offences committed before 1 July 2024.
Timeline
21 November 2026This story
Supreme Court in Dr Lokesh B H v State of Karnataka held a Section 498A IPC cruelty charge maintainable against a man in a live-in relationship with intent to marry, where he allegedly concealed an existing marriage.
1 July 2024
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita came into effect, and offences committed before this date continue to be registered under the IPC.
25 December 2023
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita received the President's assent on 25 December 2023 and replaced the IPC when it came into effect on 1 July 2024.
6 September 2018
The Supreme Court decriminalised the parts of Section 377 that criminalised same-sex relations.
11 December 2013
The Supreme Court in Suresh Kumar Koushal v Naz Foundation held that Section 377 does not suffer from unconstitutionality.
1983
Section 498A was added to the IPC to protect married women from cruel treatment by husbands and in-laws.
Relevant statutory provisions
| Provision | Subject |
|---|---|
| IPC Section 498A | Cruelty by husband or relatives |
| Domestic violence law Section 2(f) | Definition of domestic relationship |
| Hindu Marriage Act Section 5(i) | Neither party has living spouse |
| Hindu Marriage Act Section 11 | Void marriages under specified conditions |
Key terms
- Purposive interpretation:
- An approach to interpreting a legal provision in light of the purpose it seeks to achieve.
- Mischief rule:
- An interpretive approach that considers the prior law, the problem it left, the remedy provided and the remedy's purpose.
- Casus omissus:
- An omitted case or matter not provided for in a legal text.
- Void marriage:
- A marriage that the applicable law treats as null and void.
- Framing of charge:
- A procedural stage at which a court specifies the accusation to be tried; it is not a conviction.
Section 498A and live-in relationships: why it matters for exams
Exams: UPSC
Syllabus: Polity: Judiciary and statutory interpretation; Society: Women and legal protection
Common mistake: Examiners may present framing a Section 498A charge as a conviction, or claim every live-in relationship automatically attracts the provision. The Court found a charge maintainable in the particular circumstances before it.
Mains practice questions
Question 1(GS-2 | 250 words | 15 marks)
The Supreme Court's extension of Section 498A IPC to live-in relationships through the concept of 'intent to marry' has been described as judicial law-making. Critically examine whether such expansive interpretation of a criminal statute is justified in protecting women, or whether it encroaches upon the legislative domain.
Answer outline
- Introduction: Open by noting that the Court in Dr Lokesh B H v State of Karnataka held a Section 498A charge maintainable against a man in a live-in relationship who allegedly concealed an existing marriage, raising the question of how far judges may read a penal provision beyond its literal words.
- Body:
- Explain the Court's reasoning: rejection of an 'unduly technical' construction and reliance on the mischief rule and the purposive approach to protect vulnerable women from deception.
- Trace the doctrinal lineage: Reema Aggarwal (2004) extending 'husband' to void marriages, and Indra Sarma (2013) distinguishing knowing and unknowing entry into void marriages, showing an incremental judicial trajectory.
- Argue the case for purposive interpretation: remedial statutes like the Domestic Violence Act and the social reality of exploitative cohabitation justify a broader reading.
- Argue the concern: criminal law demands strict construction (principle of legality, nullum crimen sine lege); extending penal provisions by interpretation may create new offences without legislative debate and fair notice to the accused.
- Suggest a balanced remedy: legislative clarification of live-in relationships in criminal law, with judicial interpretation confined to resolving ambiguity.
- Conclusion: Conclude that while judicial purposive interpretation serves women's protection, the legitimacy of criminal law rests on legislative clarity, so Parliament should codify the position to reconcile justice for women with the rule of law.
Question 2(GS-2 | 150 words | 10 marks)
Discuss how the Supreme Court's reliance on the mischief rule in criminal statutes affects the balance between judicial interpretation and legislative supremacy, and evaluate its implications for protecting women in non-traditional domestic relationships.
Answer outline
- Introduction: Open by stating that the Court's acceptance of a Section 498A charge in a live-in relationship rests on the mischief rule, which asks what defect the legislature intended to remedy.
- Body:
- Explain the mischief rule (Heydon's case) and how it permits courts to look beyond text to the remedy Parliament intended against cruelty to women.
- Discuss the implication for legislative supremacy: courts filling gaps may appear to legislate, blurring separation of powers.
- Evaluate the gains for women in non-traditional relationships who face deception, such as concealment of an existing marriage.
- Note the risk to accused persons when penal provisions expand without clear legislative notice.
- Conclusion: Conclude that a calibrated use of the mischief rule, coupled with legislative reform, can protect vulnerable women while respecting the constitutional division of functions.
Stuck? Get it in one tap
Section 498A IPC deals with cruelty by a husband or his relatives. The Supreme Court allowed a charge under that provision to proceed in the specific Lokesh case involving a live-in relationship and intent to marry. This raises the question of whether a court can extend the wording of a criminal law in this way.
- Polity: Judiciary and statutory interpretation
- Society: Women and legal protection
Related concepts: Purposive interpretation, Mischief rule, Casus omissus, Void marriage
Practice questions
Pick an answer, then read the explanation.
- Q1Easy
Which law contains Section 2(f), defining a domestic relationship to include a relationship in the nature of marriage?
Explanation: Section 2(f) of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act defines domestic relationship. Section 498A belongs to the Indian Penal Code, while Sections 5(i) and 11 discussed here belong to the Hindu Marriage Act.
- Q2Hard
Consider the following statements:
- 1. Section 5(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act requires neither party to have a spouse living at the time of marriage.
- 2. Section 11 of the Hindu Marriage Act treats a marriage contravening Section 5(i) as void.
- 3. Section 2(f) of the domestic violence law excludes relationships in the nature of marriage from domestic relationships.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
Explanation: Statements 1 and 2 correctly describe the living-spouse condition and the consequence of its contravention. Statement 3 is incorrect: Section 2(f) includes relationships in the nature of marriage within domestic relationships.
- Q3Medium
What does the mischief rule primarily guide a court to consider when interpreting a legal remedy?
Explanation: The four-part mischief rule examines the previous law, the problem, the remedy and its purpose. Intent to marry and a marriage ceremony concern facts of a relationship, while punishment alone does not cover the four-part inquiry.
Frequently asked questions
1. Can Section 498A IPC apply to a live-in relationship?
The Supreme Court found a Section 498A charge maintainable in the particular circumstances of Dr Lokesh B H v State of Karnataka. The case involved a relationship in the nature of marriage and intent to marry.
2. What does Section 2(f) of the domestic violence law cover?
Section 2(f) defines domestic relationship and includes a relationship in the nature of marriage between persons who live or have lived together in a shared household.
3. What does Section 5(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act require?
Neither party must have a spouse living at the time of the marriage. Section 11 addresses the nullity of a marriage that contravenes this condition.
4. What are the four elements of the mischief rule?
The four elements are the prior law, the defect in that law, the remedy introduced and the purpose of the remedy.
All sources
Original21 November 2026 · Read story


