For Prelims: Right to Privacy (Article 21), IPC Section 420, CrPC Section 156(3), In Vitro Fertilisation (IVF)
For Mains: Right to privacy, Medical negligence vs criminal fraud, Civil wrong vs criminal offence, Judicial interpretation of Article 21
Source:
Hindustan
5 facts for one-day exams
SSC, railway, police and teaching exams ask direct questions like these.
- Allahabad HC ruled private CCTV cannot violate neighbour's right to privacy.
- Bench for CCTV case: Justice Ajit Kumar and Justice Garima Prasad.
- IVF failure alone does not constitute IPC Section 420 fraud.
- IVF case bench: Justice Chavan Prakash.
- Right to privacy is protected under Article 21 of the Constitution.
Why in the news?
The Allahabad High Court delivered two important rulings: (1) a private CCTV camera cannot be positioned to intrude upon a neighbour's right to privacy, and (2) failure of an IVF medical procedure does not by itself constitute criminal fraud under IPC Section 420. Both judgments reinforce the distinction between civil wrongs and criminal offences, and the constitutional right to privacy.
Summary
- Allahabad HC ruled that no individual may install a private CCTV camera in a manner that violates a neighbour's right to privacy; affected person may approach the District Magistrate.
- The court held that failure of an IVF procedure does not automatically prove criminal intent under IPC Section 420; a breach of contract is not the same as criminal fraud.
- The rulings clarify two separate legal points: the CCTV judgment affirmed the constitutional right to privacy in the context of neighbourhood surveillance, while the IVF judgment clarified the distinction between civil breaches and criminal liability in medical treatment, holding that IVF failure alone does not establish criminal fraud under IPC Section 420.
Background
The Allahabad High Court's two rulings address the growing tension between technology and privacy. In the first case, a petitioner objected to a neighbour's CCTV camera pointing at his house. In the second, a patient sued a fertility doctor for cheating after IVF failed. Both cases required the court to define the boundaries of criminal liability and fundamental rights.
Key Analysis and Impact
The CCTV ruling reaffirms the Supreme Court's 2017 judgment in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India, which declared the right to privacy a fundamental right under Article 21. The court clarified that even a private individual's surveillance can violate this right if it intrudes into another's private space. The IVF ruling is significant because it prevents routine medical failures from being criminalised; it stresses that criminal fraud under Section 420 requires proof of dishonest intention at the time of the promise, not merely a failed outcome. This protects doctors from frivolous criminal cases while preserving patients' civil remedies.
Way Forward
The court directed the petitioner in the CCTV case to approach the District Magistrate, who must decide within one month. This could set a precedent for resolving neighbourhood surveillance disputes through administrative channels rather than lengthy litigation. The IVF ruling may reduce the number of criminal complaints against medical professionals in similar cases, encouraging clearer consent forms and treatment disclaimers.
Uttar Pradesh connection
Matters for these Uttar Pradesh exams:UPPSC
Background GK
Textbook concepts you need to understand this news
- Right to Privacy (Article 21)
- The fundamental right to personal privacy, recognised by the Supreme Court in Puttaswamy (2017) as an intrinsic part of the right to life and personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution.
- IPC Section 420
- Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code deals with cheating and dishonestly inducing a person to deliver property. It requires proof of fraudulent or dishonest intention at the time of the initial promise or act.
- CrPC Section 156(3)
- Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure empowers a Magistrate to order the police to register an FIR and investigate a cognizable offence.
- In Vitro Fertilisation (IVF)
- A medical procedure where an egg is fertilised by sperm outside the body in a laboratory dish, and the resulting embryo is transferred to the uterus.
Facts to remember
Tap a card to see the answer. Try to recall it first.
How exams will ask this
- Data: Allahabad HC; Justice Ajit Kumar & Justice Garima Prasad (CCTV); Justice Chavan Prakash (IVF); IPC Section 420; CrPC Section 156(3)
- Nodal Body: Allahabad High Court
- Legal Point: Article 21 (right to privacy)
Common mistake:
Students may confuse IPC Section 420 (cheating) with other fraud sections like 406 (criminal breach of trust) or 467 (forgery). Also, they might wrongly think IVF failure always amounts to fraud, but the court clarified that without dishonest intent from the start, it is not a criminal offence.
Write these in mains answers
- Right to privacy, Medical negligence vs criminal fraud, Civil wrong vs criminal offence, Judicial interpretation of Article 21
Stuck? Get it in one tap
The Allahabad High Court gave two important rulings. First, you cannot point a private CCTV camera at your neighbour's house because it violates their right to privacy. Second, if an IVF medical procedure fails, it is not automatically a criminal fraud under IPC Section 420; a failed treatment is a civil issue, not a crime.
- Polity: Right to Privacy (Article 21)
- Governance: IPC and Criminal Procedure
Related concepts: Right to Privacy (Article 21), IPC Section 420, CrPC Section 156(3), In Vitro Fertilisation (IVF)
Practice questions
Pick an answer, then read the explanation.
- Q1Easy
Which High Court delivered the judgment that private CCTV cameras cannot violate a neighbour's right to privacy?
Explanation: The Allahabad High Court, in a bench comprising Justice Ajit Kumar and Justice Garima Prasad, delivered the ruling on CCTV and privacy. The Supreme Court recognised the right to privacy as a fundamental right in 2017, but this specific judgment came from the Allahabad HC.
- Q2Hard
Consider the following statements regarding the Allahabad High Court's rulings:
- 1.The Allahabad High Court held that a private CCTV camera may intrude upon a neighbour's right to privacy.
- 2.The Allahabad High Court held that IVF failure by itself constitutes criminal fraud under IPC Section 420.
- 3.The right to privacy invoked in the Allahabad High Court's CCTV case is protected under Article 21.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Explanation: 1. False: A private CCTV camera cannot intrude upon a neighbour's privacy. 2. False: IVF failure by itself does not constitute criminal fraud under Section 420. 3. True: The right to privacy was invoked under Article 21.
- Q3Medium
Under which section of the Indian Penal Code did the Allahabad High Court rule that IVF failure does not automatically constitute criminal fraud?
Explanation: The court ruled that failure of an IVF procedure does not automatically amount to cheating under IPC Section 420. Section 406 deals with criminal breach of trust, Section 467 with forgery of valuable security, and Section 468 with forgery for the purpose of cheating. Hence Section 420 is the correct answer.
- Q4Medium
What is the primary legal principle reaffirmed by the Allahabad High Court in its ruling on the IVF case?
Explanation: The court emphasised the distinction between a civil wrong (breach of contract) and a criminal offence (fraud). For IPC Section 420 to apply, dishonest intention must exist at the time of the promise or transaction. A failed medical procedure, without such intent, does not constitute fraud. Options A, B, and D are incorrect because medical procedures have inherent failure rates, breach of contract is civil, and liability is not automatic.
Frequently asked questions
1. What did the Allahabad High Court rule about CCTV cameras and neighbour's privacy?
The court held that a private CCTV camera cannot be installed or positioned in a way that violates a neighbour's right to privacy under Article 21 of the Constitution.
2. Does failure of an IVF procedure amount to criminal fraud under IPC Section 420?
No, the Allahabad High Court ruled that failure of an IVF procedure does not automatically constitute criminal fraud under IPC Section 420; a breach of contract is not the same as criminal fraud, which requires dishonest intent from the start.
3. Which bench of the Allahabad High Court delivered the judgment on CCTV and privacy?
The judgment was delivered by a division bench of Justice Ajit Kumar and Justice Garima Prasad.
4. What remedy did the court provide to the petitioner in the CCTV case?
The court directed the petitioner to submit a formal application to the District Magistrate, who must decide on it within one month as per rules.
All sources
Original3 November 2026 · Read story

