Super Current Affairs

Polity

Patna High Court: Pre-absorption scheme service excluded from seniority, counted for pension

19 November 20263 min1 source4 questionsStory 11 of 42

For Prelims: Seniority, Absorption, Regularisation, Division bench

For Mains: Governance: Civil services and public administration; Polity: High Courts and judicial review

Source:Indian ExpressIndian Express

The news

The Patna High Court has ruled that an employee appointed under centrally sponsored Adult Education and Non-Formal Education schemes cannot claim seniority, pay fixation or promotion benefits on the basis of the years he worked under those schemes before being absorbed into regular government service. Justices Mohit Kumar Shah and Sourendra Pandey, while dismissing the employee’s appeal on November 18, noted that the absorption order treated his appointment as a fresh one and specifically excluded seniority and other service benefits based on his earlier employment.

The employee was initially appointed as an accounts clerk on a temporary and ad hoc basis for three months in 1985 under the Adult Education Scheme. After that scheme closed in 1992, he was absorbed into the Non-Formal Education Scheme, which was discontinued on March 31, 2001, leading to his termination effective April 1, 2001. In 2006, the Bihar government absorbed him into the Welfare Department as a clerk-cum-accountant, but the absorption order stated that his previous service would not count towards seniority or other service benefits, although it would be considered for pension. The court held that employment under such centrally sponsored schemes is not part of the formal cadre of the state government, and that long service under a discontinued project does not automatically confer a right to permanency or regularisation.

Patna High Court scheme service seniority: why in the news?

The Patna High Court’s November 18 ruling clarifies that service under centrally sponsored schemes does not count for seniority or promotion after absorption into regular government service, affecting employees in similar situations across Bihar.

What was the employee’s argument?

The employee, represented by advocate Rajnish Kumar, argued that the order terminating his services, dated September 16, 2001, was unconstitutional and that he was entitled to have his earlier service under the central schemes counted for seniority and promotional benefits. The state government, represented by additional advocate general Sarvesh Kumar Singh, countered that the absorption was a compassionate policy decision and was explicitly treated as a fresh appointment, making the claim for seniority from the date of scheme engagement wholly misconceived.

How did the court distinguish pension from seniority?

The court noted that the authority had been “generous enough” to allow the employee’s earlier service to be considered for pension under the absorption arrangement. However, it clarified that pensionary benefits from scheme employment do not equate to a right to seniority or promotion, as the scheme employment was not under any establishment of the state government and was funded through central grants. The court pointed out that once a scheme is discontinued, employees engaged under it cannot claim a right to continue in service or seek regularisation in another project or service.

Treatment of earlier scheme service

BenefitTreatment under absorption
SeniorityNot counted
PromotionNot counted
PensionConsidered

Bihar connection

Bihar

Matters for these Bihar exams:BPSC

Patna High Court scheme service seniority: facts and terms for exams

Seniority:
Seniority is the relative position of employees in a service or cadre, determined under applicable service rules.
Absorption:
Absorption is the placement of an employee in another establishment or service under specified terms.
Regularisation:
Regularisation is the process of giving an eligible employee regular service status under applicable rules or orders.
Division bench:
A division bench is a court bench comprising two or more judges.

Patna High Court scheme service seniority: why it matters for exams

Exams: BPSC

Syllabus: Governance: Civil services and public administration; Polity: High Courts and judicial review

Common mistake: Examiners may present pension eligibility as identical to seniority eligibility: the earlier service was considered for pension but not for seniority or promotion in this case.

Mains question on Patna High Court scheme service seniority

Examine the distinction made by the Patna High Court between counting service under centrally sponsored schemes for pension versus for seniority and promotion. How does this affect the rights of scheme employees absorbed into regular government service? Discuss.

Stuck? Get it in one tap

Practice questions

Pick an answer, then read the explanation.

  1. Q1Easy

    Which court dismissed the appeal concerning an absorbed Bihar employee’s seniority based on centrally sponsored scheme service?

  2. Q2Hard

    Consider the following statements about the Patna High Court’s decision on the absorbed Bihar employee:

    • 1. His 2006 absorption was treated as a fresh appointment.
    • 2. Earlier scheme service was allowed to be considered for pension.
    • 3. Earlier scheme service automatically gave him seniority from 1985.

    Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  3. Q3Medium

    In which year was the employee in the Patna High Court service-benefits case absorbed into Bihar government service?

  4. Q4Medium

    Why did the Patna High Court reject the Bihar employee’s claim to seniority based on earlier scheme service?

Frequently asked questions

1. Did the Patna High Court count earlier scheme service for promotion?

No. The employee’s absorption was treated as a fresh appointment, excluding earlier service for seniority and promotion.

2. Was the Bihar employee’s earlier scheme service considered for pension?

Yes. The absorption arrangement allowed his earlier service to be considered for pension.

3. When was the Bihar employee absorbed into regular government service?

He was absorbed in 2006, subject to the terms of a fresh appointment.

4. Does long ad hoc service under a scheme automatically give a right to regularisation?

No. The Patna High Court held that long ad hoc service under a scheme does not automatically confer permanency or regularisation.

All sources

Stories from the last 30 days on the same topic, state or exams

PolityBiharBPSC: Very important

Patna HC: Terminating advocate’s services not by itself defamation

  • Judge: Justice Ramesh Chand Malviya
  • Key Principle: Termination of a professional engagement is not, by itself, defamation
Background GK: Defamation (Civil and Criminal)Section 499 IPC; Advocates Act, 1961Nodal: Patna High CourtDon't make this mistake!
4 questions · 3 minIndian Express
PolityUttar PradeshUPPSC: Important

UP teachers' pension: 2023 order limits ad hoc service count

  • Regularisation provision: Section 33-G, Uttar Pradesh Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982
  • Amended pension rule: Rule 19(B), Uttar Pradesh Contributory Provident Fund Insurance Pension Rules, 1965
Background GK: Qualifying serviceSection 33-G; Rule 19(B)Don't make this mistake!Complete guide: Uttar Pradesh Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982
3 questions · 3 minHindustan