Super Current Affairs

Polity

Victim Compensation Under BNSS: Supreme Court Recognises Rehabilitation Even After Acquittal

16 November 20263 min2 sources4 questionsStory 3 of 94

Source:HindustanHindustan

Subject: Governance, Judiciary and Social Justice (victim compensation, criminal justice reform)|Target exams: UPSC

Key points for Prelims: Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), Victim compensation scheme, District Legal Services Authority, Acquittal and discharge, Rehabilitation of victims

Mains syllabus mapping

  • General Studies Paper 2: Indian Constitution and judiciary: role of Supreme Court, judicial pronouncements, legal aid and access to justice
  • General Studies Paper 2: Governance and welfare schemes for vulnerable sections: victim rehabilitation, state responsibility
  • General Studies Paper 3: Internal security and criminal justice reforms: new criminal laws (BNSS), victim-centric justice

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023: quick facts

Parliament passage and assent
Passed by Lok Sabha on 20 December 2023 and Rajya Sabha on 21 December 2023; received the President's assent on 25 December 2023
Structure
39 chapters and 531 sections, plus two schedules
Victim compensation provision
Section 396 BNSS: every State Government, in coordination with the Central Government, must prepare a scheme for providing compensation funds to victims or dependants who suffered loss or injury and need rehabilitation

Key facts for one-day exams

  • The Bhiwani killings occurred on 17 April 2011.
  • The victims were Shakuntala and Suman.
  • Ranila village is in Haryana's Bhiwani district.
  • A Bhiwani fast-track court sentenced Naresh to death in 2013.
  • Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and N. Kotiswar Singh formed the Supreme Court bench.

Victim compensation under BNSS: why in the news?

The Supreme Court has ruled that victim compensation under the BNSS can be considered even after an acquittal, directing the District Legal Services Authority, Bhiwani, to assess financial assistance for the families of two murdered women. The observation clarifies that a failed prosecution does not bar rehabilitation support for victims' families.

The Supreme Court on Monday said that families of murder victims may deserve financial compensation even when the accused is acquitted, because the loss suffered by the family does not disappear when the prosecution fails to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. A bench of Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and N. Kotiswar Singh made the observation while acquitting Naresh, who had been sentenced to death in 2013 by a Bhiwani fast-track court for the 2011 killing of two widows in Haryana. The court directed the District Legal Services Authority, Bhiwani, to examine whether the families of the two women can receive assistance under the victim compensation scheme.

The case relates to the murder of Shakuntala and Suman, both widows, in Ranila village, Bhiwani district, on 17 April 2011. According to the prosecution, Naresh and another person, Subhash, dragged the women from their homes and beat them to death with sticks, accusing Suman of having a relationship with her aunt Shakuntala. Police arrested both accused two days after the murder. The Supreme Court acquitted Naresh after finding the evidence insufficient to sustain the conviction. The bench said that under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) provisions on victim compensation, courts can recommend compensation even when a trial ends in acquittal or discharge, provided the victim or dependants need rehabilitation. The court called on state governments to frame compensation schemes in coordination with the central government.

Key features and how it works

  • Section 396(1): State Governments, in coordination with the Central Government, prepare a scheme providing funds for compensation to a victim or dependants who suffered loss or injury from a crime and need rehabilitation.indiankanoon.org
  • Section 396(2) and (5): the District or State Legal Services Authority decides the quantum of compensation and awards it after due enquiry, which must be completed within two months.indiankanoon.org
  • Section 396(3): if the trial court finds the compensation under Section 395 inadequate, or the case ends in acquittal or discharge and the victim needs rehabilitation, the court may recommend compensation.indiankanoon.org
  • Section 396(4): where the offender is not traced or identified, the victim is identified, and no trial takes place, the victim or dependants can apply to the State or District Legal Services Authority for compensation.indiankanoon.org
  • Section 396(6): the Legal Services Authority can order free first-aid or medical benefits, or other interim relief, to alleviate the victim's suffering.indiankanoon.org
  • Section 396(7): the compensation payable by the State Government is in addition to any fine paid to the victim under Sections 65, 70 and 124(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.indiankanoon.org
  • Zero FIR: Section 173 gives statutory recognition to Zero FIR, so an FIR can be registered at any police station regardless of territorial jurisdiction.

Eligibility and key provisions

  1. Who can get compensation under Section 396: the victim or dependants who suffered loss or injury from a crime and who require rehabilitation.indiankanoon.org
  2. Where the case ends in acquittal or discharge, the victim or dependants must still need rehabilitation for the court to recommend compensation.indiankanoon.org
  3. Where no offender is traced or identified, the victim is identified, and no trial takes place, the victim or dependants can apply directly to the State or District Legal Services Authority.indiankanoon.org

Related Static GK and comparison

  • National Legal Services Authority (NALSA): founded 9 November 1995 under the Legal Services Authorities Act 1987, a statutory body that provides free legal services and organises Lok Adalats; the Chief Justice of India is its patron-in-chief.
  • Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987: enacted to give effect to Article 39A of the Constitution on free legal aid.

BNSS victim compensation vs NALSA Compensation Scheme 2018 for women victims

BasisBNSS Section 396 (victim compensation scheme)NALSA Compensation Scheme for Women Victims/Survivors (2018)
Legal basisSection 396 of the BNSS, 2023Scheme framed by NALSA following Supreme Court orders in Nipun Saxena vs Union of India (2018 order)
Who prepares the schemeEvery State Government in coordination with the Central GovernmentNational Legal Services Authority
Target groupVictims or dependants who suffered loss or injury from any crime and need rehabilitationWomen victims or survivors of sexual assault and other crimes
Who decides the amountDistrict or State Legal Services Authority after enquiryState Legal Services Authority, where applications are made
Application routeCourt recommendation after trial, or direct application where offender is not tracedApplication to the State Legal Services Authority with FIR, medical reports and judgment or recommendation

Achievements

  • The BNSS allows compensation to be recommended even after acquittal, so a family's loss is recognised even where the prosecution fails to prove guilt.
  • The law makes compensation available through an enquiry by the legal services authority, which must finish within two months, giving victims a time-bound route.indiankanoon.org
  • Interim relief such as free first aid or medical benefits can be ordered quickly, before the final award.indiankanoon.org

Challenges

  1. Compensation depends on each State Government framing its own scheme, so benefits may vary between states.
  2. Eligibility rests on proof that the victim needs rehabilitation, which can be hard to show after an acquittal.
  3. Victims often do not know about the scheme or the legal services route, so awareness and documentation can be the real barrier.

Way forward

  • States should frame and notify their compensation schemes in coordination with the Centre, as the Supreme Court called for.
  • Legal services authorities can provide handholding so families know how to apply and what documents to attach.
  • Monitoring of the two-month enquiry deadline and of award payments would show whether the scheme reaches victims in practice.

Key terms

Acquittal:
A judicial finding that an accused is not guilty of the charge tried.
Beyond reasonable doubt:
The standard of proof generally required to establish guilt in a criminal trial.
Victim compensation:
Financial assistance provided under a compensation framework to address a victim's loss, injury or rehabilitation needs.

Victim compensation under BNSS: why it matters for exams

Exams: UPSC

Syllabus: Polity: Judiciary and criminal justice; Governance: Victim compensation and rehabilitation

Common mistake: Examiners may present acquittal as an automatic bar to compensation or as an automatic guarantee of payment; compensation can be considered where rehabilitation is needed.

Mains question on Victim compensation under BNSS

Discuss the significance of the Supreme Court's observation that victim compensation under the BNSS can be considered even after acquittal. How does this balance the rights of the accused and the needs of victims?

Stuck? Get it in one tap

Practice questions

Pick an answer, then read the explanation.

  1. Q1Easy

    Which body was directed to examine possible compensation for the families of the two women killed in Bhiwani?

  2. Q2Hard

    Consider the following statements about victim compensation under the BNSS:

    1. 1.Courts can recommend compensation even when a trial ends in acquittal or discharge, if rehabilitation is needed.
    2. 2.An acquittal automatically guarantees compensation to every victim's family.
    3. 3.Victims' dependants can be considered under the compensation framework.

    Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  3. Q3Medium

    In which year did the killings of Shakuntala and Suman in Bhiwani district occur?

  4. Q4Medium

    Why can victim compensation be considered after an accused is acquitted under the BNSS framework?

Frequently asked questions

1. Can a victim's family receive compensation after an acquittal under the BNSS?

Compensation can be considered after acquittal when the victim or dependants need rehabilitation; payment is not automatic.

2. Who will assess possible assistance for the Bhiwani victims' families?

The District Legal Services Authority, Bhiwani, will examine the victim compensation scheme and possible financial assistance.

3. Why did the Supreme Court acquit Naresh in the Bhiwani case?

The Supreme Court found the evidence insufficient to prove his guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

4. Who can be covered by the BNSS victim compensation framework?

Victims or their dependants who suffer loss or injury and need rehabilitation can be considered.

All sources

Stories from the last 30 days on the same topic, state or exams

PolityRajasthanRPSC RAS: Very important

SC: No monopoly on voter awareness campaigns by election bodies

  • Full form of BNSS: Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023
  • Nodal body for panchayat elections in Rajasthan: Rajasthan State Election Commission (SEC)
New updateBackground GK: State Election Commission (SEC)Section 163, BNSS 2023Nodal: Supreme Court of IndiaDon't make this mistake!
4 questions · 2 minThe HinduIndian ExpressHindustan
PolityMaharashtraUPSC: Important

Zero FIR under BNSS: procedural gaps for survivors

  • Legal Provision: Section 173, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS)
  • Recommended By: Justice Verma Committee (2013)
Background GK: Zero FIRSection 173, BNSSNodal: Ministry of Home AffairsDon't make this mistake!
3 questions · 2 minIndian Express