Source:Dainik Bhaskar
Subject: Indian Polity: Fundamental Rights, Reservation and Judicial Review|Target exams: UPSC, UPPSC, UPPSC RO/ARO
Key points for Prelims: Article 15(4), Article 16(4A) and 16(4B), Article 330 and 334, Kesavananda Bharati case, Writ of prohibition
Mains syllabus mapping
- General Studies Paper 2: Constitutional provisions, fundamental rights, reservation and equality; judiciary and judicial review
- General Studies Paper 1: Social empowerment and issues of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
Key facts for one-day exams
- The Allahabad High Court's Lucknow Bench dismissed the SC-ST reservation petition.
- Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and Justice Jaspreet Singh constituted the bench.
- Advocate Mahendra Pratap Singh filed the petition.
- Article 15(4) was added by the First Constitutional Amendment.
- The court referred to the Kesavananda Bharati decision.
SC-ST reservation constitutional challenge: why in the news?
The Allahabad High Court has dismissed a petition that directly challenged the constitutional validity of SC-ST reservation provisions, reaffirming that providing opportunities to disadvantaged groups is part of constitutional equality.
The Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court has dismissed a public interest litigation that sought to declare the constitutional reservation provisions for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes unconstitutional. The division bench of Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and Justice Jaspreet Singh rejected the petition filed by advocate Mahendra Pratap Singh, which had asked the court to restrain the Union and state governments from implementing Articles 15(4), 16(4A), 16(4B), 330 and 334.
The court held that the petition suffered from several legal defects, including an improper legal basis, the wrong remedy sought, and the failure to make all state governments parties despite seeking relief against them. The bench noted that a writ of prohibition, which the petitioner had sought, is meant to restrain judicial or quasi-judicial authorities from exceeding their jurisdiction and cannot be issued against governments in the manner requested. The court also referred to the Kesavananda Bharati judgment, emphasising that constitutional provisions require a substantial basis for challenge.
Rejecting the petitioner's argument that reservation contradicts the constitutional principle of equality, the bench explained that constitutional equality is not limited to identical status and opportunities. Providing the necessary opportunities and facilities to bring socially disadvantaged groups to an equal level is also part of achieving constitutional equality, the court said. The petitioner had argued that Article 15(4), introduced by the First Constitutional Amendment, violated equality and that the continued extension of reservation went against the original intent of a time-bound arrangement. The court dismissed the petition on these grounds.
What did the Kesavananda Bharati case decide?
The Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala case, decided by a 13-judge Supreme Court bench in 1973, established the basic structure doctrine. The court held that while Parliament has wide powers to amend the Constitution under Article 368, it cannot alter or destroy its basic structure. Fundamental rights, secularism, federalism, and the rule of law are among the features the court has since identified as part of this basic structure. The Allahabad High Court referred to this judgment to underline that constitutional provisions, including those on reservation, rest on a strong foundation and cannot be challenged lightly.
Which provisions were challenged?
The petition sought to stop the implementation of five constitutional provisions: Article 15(4), which enables special provisions for backward classes and SC/ST; Article 16(4A), which deals with reservation in promotions, and Article 16(4B), which deals with carrying forward unfilled reserved vacancies as a separate class; and Article 330, which provides for SC/ST seat reservation in the Lok Sabha, and Article 334, which concerns the duration of reservation and Anglo-Indian representation in legislatures. The petitioner also cited Article 17, which abolishes untouchability, arguing that the use of the term 'Scheduled Caste' contradicts its spirit.
What did the court say about equality?
The division bench rejected the petitioner's narrow reading of equality. The court held that constitutional equality is not confined to identical status and opportunities; it also includes providing the facilities and opportunities needed to bring socially disadvantaged groups to an equal level. The court said it is not proper to call the reservation system contradictory by ignoring constitutional ideals. The decision leaves the challenged provisions unaffected.
Uttar Pradesh connection
Matters for these Uttar Pradesh exams:UPPSCUPPSC RO/ARO
Key terms
- Public Interest Litigation:
- A judicial proceeding brought to protect or enforce an issue affecting the public interest.
- Writ of Prohibition:
- A judicial order preventing a judicial or quasi-judicial authority from acting beyond its jurisdiction.
- Article 15(4):
- A constitutional provision enabling special provisions for socially and educationally backward classes of citizens or for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.
- Article 17:
- The constitutional provision abolishing untouchability and forbidding its practice in any form.
- Basic Structure Doctrine:
- The principle that Parliament's power to amend the Constitution does not extend to destroying its basic structure.
SC-ST reservation constitutional challenge: why it matters for exams
Exams: UPSC, UPPSC, UPPSC RO/ARO
Syllabus: Polity: Equality, reservation and fundamental rights; Polity: Writs and public interest litigation
Common mistake: Examiners may present a writ of prohibition as a remedy directed against governments; the court identified it as a writ restraining judicial or quasi-judicial authorities from exceeding jurisdiction.
Mains practice questions
Question 1(GS-2 | 150 words | 10 marks)
Evaluate the role of Public Interest Litigation in constitutional matters, with reference to the dismissal of the petition challenging SC-ST reservation provisions before the Allahabad High Court.
Answer outline
- Introduction: Mention that the Allahabad High Court dismissed a PIL against SC-ST reservation provisions on grounds of legal defects, raising the question of how PIL should be used in constitutional disputes.
- Body:
- Point out PIL's value in expanding access to justice and enabling public-spirited challenges to executive or legislative action.
- Point out the misuse concern when PILs raise contested policy questions or seek remedies that are legally improper, as the court found here.
- Mention the procedural requirements, such as correct remedy and joinder of necessary parties, that safeguard the quality of constitutional litigation.
- Conclusion: PIL remains a useful tool when it is legally well-founded, and courts must keep screening weak petitions so that the tool serves constitutional values rather than contested political agendas.
Stuck? Get it in one tap
The Allahabad High Court rejected a challenge to constitutional provisions concerning SC-ST reservation. The court explained that equality can require opportunities and facilities for disadvantaged groups. The petition also sought an inappropriate writ and failed to include the state governments against which it requested relief.
- Polity: Equality, reservation and fundamental rights
- Polity: Writs and public interest litigation
Related concepts: Public Interest Litigation, Writ of Prohibition, Article 15(4), Article 17
Practice questions
Pick an answer, then read the explanation.
- Q1Easy
Which constitutional article did the First Constitutional Amendment add, as discussed in the SC-ST reservation petition?
Explanation: Article 15(4) was added through the First Constitutional Amendment. Articles 17, 330 and 334 were also discussed in the petition, but were not identified as the provision added by that amendment.
- Q2Hard
Consider the following statements about the Allahabad High Court's SC-ST reservation decision:
- 1. The court accepted that a writ of prohibition could be issued against the governments as requested.
- 2. The petition sought relief against all state governments without making them parties.
- 3. The court held that equality can include opportunities and facilities for socially disadvantaged groups.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
Explanation: Statement 1 is incorrect: the court rejected the requested writ against the governments. Statements 2 and 3 are correct: the bench identified non-joinder and recognized supportive opportunities as part of equality.
- Q3Medium
How many constitutional provisions were listed in the petition seeking to stop implementation of SC-ST reservation provisions?
Explanation: The petition listed five provisions: Articles 15(4), 16(4A), 16(4B), 330 and 334. The other counts do not match that list.
- Q4Medium
What understanding of constitutional equality did the Allahabad High Court apply in the SC-ST reservation petition?
Explanation: The bench treated support for socially disadvantaged groups as part of constitutional equality. It rejected identical treatment as the sole measure of equality; joining parties and selecting a writ are procedural questions, not definitions of equality.
Frequently asked questions
1. What did the Allahabad High Court decide on the SC-ST reservation petition?
The Lucknow Bench dismissed the petition seeking to invalidate constitutional reservation provisions.
2. Which constitutional provisions were challenged in the SC-ST reservation petition?
The petition sought to stop implementation of Articles 15(4), 16(4A), 16(4B), 330 and 334.
3. What did the Allahabad High Court say about equality and reservation?
Constitutional equality includes providing opportunities and facilities needed to bring socially disadvantaged groups to an equal level.
4. Why did the Allahabad High Court reject the requested writ of prohibition?
A writ of prohibition restrains judicial or quasi-judicial authorities from exceeding jurisdiction; it cannot be issued against governments in the manner requested.
All sources
Original19 November 2026 · Read story


